Re: [Caml-list] Hashtbls with physical equality?

[Wheeler Ruml <ruml@parc.com>]

Hi Brian,

Thanks for your reply.

> > Is it possible in OCaml to have a hash table that can insert and retrieve
> > values without walking over their structure?  I tried to hack something
> > together using Obj.magic
> 
> There is no magic value associated with objects, unlike Java.

OK - thanks.

> > I have a hash table
> > of strings and I'd like to avoid traversing their length on every lookup.
> > Do I have to explicitly use integers instead?
>
> [...] I think what you're asking for is impossible.

Yeah, seems that way.  I think I'll explicitly associate an integer with
each string, along the lines of what you suggest.

> The nice thing about balanced trees is that they're O(log N) worst case.
> [...]  Getting it working first, then worry about performance.

Thanks for the tips - good advice.  Happily, it already works, and a factor
of two in performance actually does matter in my application.

Best,

Wheeler
-- 
Wheeler Ruml, Palo Alto Research Center, Rm 1522, 650-812-4329 voice
ruml@parc.com, http://www.parc.com/ruml           650-812-4334 fax